Archive for January 11th, 2014

January 11, 2014

2012 Columbia Crest Two Vines Riesling; 2011 Domaines André Aubert Le Devoy Rouge; The Franc, Consentino Cabernet Franc, Lodi, 2012

Everything Wine Wine Club, December 2013: Six different wines, two bottles of each.  Here is a review of half of the EW box from Christmas.


2012 Columbia Crest Two Vines Riesling

Light, appealing, in the Alsace style.  Loaded with stone fruit flavour, a tad sweet with just a light hit of acidity.  Delectable and low in alcohol.  A cheese souffle marriage.


Price: $22.99 at Everything Wine

Market Liquidity: Easy like Sunday morning.


2011 Domaines André Aubert Le Devoy Rouge

Unbelievably gorgeous red.  Stupendous value.  If in BC, where the wine tax is sky high, we’re paying under $20 for wine this good, it beggars the mind what the French pay; maybe it’s on a spigot at the local bistro?


From the get go this has all the hallmarks of a new world red, astonishingly good, a deep purple hue with sharp notes of blueberry, cherry, plum and an undercurrent of barnyard hay and leather.  Appealing as an aperitif, creamy with a meat main.  Only thing that held back higher praise was it’s (also new world-ish) high alcohol; 14.5%.  We thought that was banned in France?

Price: $19.99 at Everything Wine

Market Liquidity: Gold, Jerry, Gold.


The Franc, Consentino Cabernet Franc, Lodi, 2012

Ah Chinon.  Nothing like being in a French village and ordering a reasonably priced bottle of Chinon.  So it was a surprise and maybe even a novelty to see a Cab Franc included in the mixed lot.009


The Lodi Cabernet Franc proclaims itself a “cashmere” of reds. I will give it its due; it drinks smoothly, easily, and is a brilliant new world example of the varietal.  But it’s also a bit like being in a cigar store; heady and appealing but ultimately overwhelming.  We found it both lovely but a bit tiring, if you get my drift.


Price: $26.99 at Everything Wine

Market Liquidity: In the words of Mr. Burns, too much dancing, not enough prancing.

January 11, 2014

Rioja Reserva, Muga, 2008

090This wine carries the weight of “significant” reviews and high points, trying to live up to the influence of the point scale.  But it also faces shelf space against myriad fine Spanish reds which have flooded the shelves the last few years.  And in both cases, our verdict is that it’s losing.


Sure, it’s an easy drinker.  But I would call it demure, if such a word has ever been used in a wine review, without the surprise, zing or luxe of so many competitors.  It would, most likely, please most of the people most of the time, with its simplicity, softness, and lovely finish.  But what of the flavour and depth and layers of interest most Rioja holds?  Scant.  We were hard pressed to even come up with six simple adjectives characterizing its drinkability. It is apparently mainly Grenache but it drank more Tempranillo.


If your rich uncle is buying, get a half case.  But if it’s your own pocketbook, I’d be inclined to spend ten bucks less for something just as good.


Price: $28 at BC Liquor


Market Liquidity: A good wine, not a great wine.

January 11, 2014

Stags’ Leap 2009 Napa Valley Petite Sirah

079AKA Shiraz.  Toxically good.  An arresting red with a sharp hook that is immediately appealing and alluring.  Minerally and medicinal, coarse berry notes, blackberry and black currant, pepper and the sort of concord grape juice flavour you might get in a jelly candy.  But without the sweet; this is dry dry.


There is an earthiness to this wine, something that seems unchanged over time.  When we were in South Africa a few years back, the Cape had a lot of red wines which tasted as though the Huguenots who brought the oak and vines were still plodding about in the fields, as if we’d left all the Vinotopia tinkering behind and were left with just good craft.  This vintage was like that experience; it drank like a find at an antique market.  Not what we were expecting, not soft and eloquent and airbrushed to elicit the points and esteem.  Although worthy of course.  See our stunningly reverse experience with a mediocre Stags Leap here.009


Price: A hefty $40 USD.  But it was after all in keeping with the Christmas spirit.


Market Liquidity: Oldy Worldy in a good way.